East & West – Why a Difference in Approach to Caring for Older People?

Elderly care is part of the health care system focused on the well-being of senior citizens. From conditions like dementia and depression to changes in diet and physical activity levels, caring for elderly loved ones is an unavoidable challenge for many families.

There are many different approaches to elderly care, depending on the culture and region where the care is taking place. In general, there are two different approaches to elderly care – the Eastern approach and the Western approach.

The Difference in Approach – Why and What:

Elderly care in the East is often considered a family responsibility, while in the West, it’s typically left to professional caregivers. There are a few reasons for this difference in approach.

In the East, filial piety is an important Confucian value that dictates that children are obligated to care for their parents. It is still a part of East Asian culture, even in modern times. It is common for elderly relatives to live with their children and grandchildren. This extended family support system provides a wide range of services and care that helps keep seniors healthy and happy. While this arrangement has its challenges, it seems to work well for many families in Asia.

In contrast, Westerners have always placed a high value on independence and self-reliance. This view is embodied in the concept of “ageing in place.” In many cases, this approach is successful. However, there are situations where older adults need more help than what can be provided within the home environment. In these cases, the elderly may move to a nursing home or assisted living facility. Most Westerners see this as a last resort, only to be used when absolutely necessary.

Do Assisted Care Facilities Provide Better Care?

One of the main arguments for the Western approach to elderly care is that professional caregivers in assisted living facilities can provide a higher standard of care than what is possible at home. They back their claims with statistics showing that seniors in assisted living facilities have a lower risk of injury, experience fewer health problems, and live longer than those who receive care at home.

There is some truth to these claims. Assisted living facilities do have many advantages.

Properly designed for the needs of seniors. From non-slip flooring to railings for support, these facilities are designed with the safety and well-being of residents in mind. The nurse call system is a great example of how this care is provided. This system allows seniors to summon help with the push of a button, even if they can’t speak.

They also offer a range of amenities and activities that can help keep seniors engaged and active.

Additionally, most assisted living facilities have staff that’s available 24 hours a day, seven days a week. It means that there’s always someone on hand to provide assistance and care if needed.


The decision of whether to choose an Eastern or Western approach to elderly care is a personal one. There are pros and cons to both approaches. Ultimately, the best decision is the one that meets the unique needs of the senior citizen in question. Before you announce what works for you, consider the comfort, safety, and happiness of your elderly loved one. After all, that’s what’s most important.